How many logical mistakes are there in The Legend of the Condor Heroes? What do you think of this?

As a masterpiece of Jin Yong's martial arts, Legend of the Condor Heroes has many bright spots, but it was serialized in Ming Pao at that time, which inevitably left some flaws. However, with Jin Yong's several revisions, some have been revised, but the big plot cannot be changed. Let's see how many illogical plots there are in the novel. Most of these plots are related to Huang.

First, Huang Rong is bigger than Guo Jing.

Huang Rong, Guo Jing.

Guo Jing met Huang Rong when he returned to the Central Plains from the desert for the first time. They loved each other and fell in love at first sight. It is mentioned in the book that Huang Rong is two years younger than Guo Jing, and Huang Rong has always called Guo Jing Jing Ge in the book. We don't think there is any problem. But according to the development logic of the plot in the book, Huang's disciple was driven out of Peach Blossom Island because Huang Rong's mother died in childbirth, and when he met Qu Lingfeng, the owner of the bar, Qu San, Guo Jing Yang Kang was not born yet, so Huang Rong was older than Guo Jing. Is Jing Rong's love, which has been talked about by people, a sister-in-law relationship?

This is a logical error in the serial version and the triple version. It is estimated that Jin Yong himself did not pay much attention to this plot, otherwise it would not have remained unchanged. However, this plot was forcibly corrected in the new revision of the century. Why is it forced? It is because Jin Yong pushed Qu Lingfeng out of Peach Blossom Island in advance, and the reason is very reluctant. It actually involves the love of Qu Lingfeng, Mei Chaofeng and even Huang Sijiao. As a big brother, Qu Lingfeng fell in love with Mei Chaofeng and had a big fight with his rival in love, which caused Huang, who had been silently fond of Mei Chaofeng, to interrupt Qu Lingfeng's legs and drive him out of Peach Blossom Island. Is it a little messy?

Second, why do Chen Xuanfeng and Mei Chaofeng have to go to Peach Blossom Island?

Mei chaofeng

Why did Chen Xuanfeng and Mei Chaofeng betray their heritage? Because they're in love? When two people fall in love, they don't have to go to Peach Blossom Island. Will Huang hug them both? Even if Huang likes Mei Chaofeng in the new version of the sculpture, he won't object to being together. After all, Huang Shiyou did not express his love for Mei Chaofeng. He married Huang Rong's mother, Feng Heng. And the triple version of Huang has never liked Mei Chaofeng, so why did they both escape? It doesn't make any sense for the sake of Jiuyin Zhen Jing. Huang is their master, and sooner or later, the master will pass on the nine Yin to his disciples. Why risk stealing? Is it interesting to live a life of fear in the Jianghu?

3. Chen Can Feng Xuan carved the second half of Jiuyin Zhen Jing on his chest?

Chen Xuanfeng and Mei Chaofeng stole half of the Nine Yin Zhen Classics, but Chen Xuanfeng carved it on his chest and never showed it to Mei Chaofeng, so he didn't take off his clothes even if he was affectionate. What? Is it okay? Therefore, Mei Chaofeng has never seen what Jiuyin Zhenjing looks like. It was not until he was killed by Jing that he said that he would carve the "Nine Yin Zhen Jing" on his chest skin and let Mei Chaofeng cut off his skin. Finally, the leather version of the Nine Yin Scriptures was stolen by Sir Zhong to Guo Jing. But here's the problem. Even if the book is half full, it is estimated that there are many words. Otherwise, Huang Rong's mother wouldn't have died during childbirth. Can a person's chest be carved? Even if it can be carved, how did Chen Xuanfeng carve it himself without help?

Fourth, there were many opportunities to get rid of Ouyang Feng, but it didn't happen.

Feng Ouyang

Ouyang Feng is the super villain in the book. He is ruthless and does all kinds of evil. Ten Bi Qiu is not worth one Ouyang Feng. However, it is inconceivable that such a wicked man should live to the age of condor heroes and perish together with a hero like Hong Qigong. Look at Ouyang Feng's evil deeds. He killed Tan Chuduan, Mei Chaofeng and the Five Monsters in the South of the Yangtze River. He even nearly killed Hong Qigong and Huang, saying that he was full of evil. But obviously there are many opportunities to get rid of Ouyang Feng, but no one laid hands on him. Guo Jinglian let him go three times. Have you forgotten how your five masters died? Have you forgotten that he almost killed Hong Qigong? Shouldn't such a person be chopped to pieces? Just because he is a villain, does he stay until the end to die?

5. Food that should not have appeared in the Song Dynasty? peanut

The owner of this small hotel is a cripple. With two crutches, he slowly scalded two pots of rice wine, placed a plate of broad beans, a plate of salted peanuts, a plate of dried tofu and three sliced salted eggs. He sat alone on the bench at the door, looking up at the setting sun in the sky, but didn't even look at the three of them. ? The first snowstorm in The Legend of the Condor Heroes has undergone earth-shaking changes.

Peanut surprise in the dishes of Niujiacun bistro! If there were headlines in the Song Dynasty, Qu Lingfeng's pub would definitely make headlines, because peanuts are very common now, but peanuts were brought back by Zheng He's voyage to the West in the Ming Dynasty. How could there be such a rarity at that time? But this is not a logical error. Jin Yong should also write casually. Why do you want to study when peanuts came from China?

Summary: There are some minor problems in a novel that are actually harmless, and it does not prevent this novel from becoming a classic handed down from generation to generation. We don't have to worry too much about these small problems, as long as we get happiness from reading. Little friends don't have to be too serious, and entertainment is paramount.