If not, it may really be that you think too much, and long-term pain is better than short-term pain. I suggest you divide it.
You can ask him how he feels about you. If he admits his love for you, you might as well give him another chance. If he is as good as you think, you'd better break up, or you may end up hurting yourself.
There are some things that you will never know until you tell each other. Someone must break the wall.